Will the House continue to repeal Obamacare every week?
Will the search for the truth about Benghazi continue eternally?
Boehner gave Ryan a fantastic going away present with the debt ceiling deal, so Ryan should be able to avoid any "shutdown" crisis until Obama is gone.
Well let's see, perhaps the new speaker can take up tax reform, put forth legislation to undue Citizens United, I know...how about immigration reform.
All these issues are being discussed by the potential 2016 nominees, I say let the Republican controlled House and Senate start now. Since there is no guarantee they'll win the W.H., it'll give them something to do until election.
We could HAVE more gridlock? At least a Democratically controlled Senate will keep the brain dead idiots in the "Freedom Caucus" in the House in check if Ryan can't.
That's true. Romney is waiting in the wings to be there Convention compromise candidate. He'd jump at the chance to lose the White House again. It would make him feel "relevant" again.
No one seriously believes Trump or Carson will be the GOP nominee. Even the GOP average voter is not that stupid. It'll be an establishment candidate because if it IS Trump or Carson, it'll be Goldwater all over again. A GOP version of what 1972 was like for the Democrats. Maybe worse. It'll be Rubio or Bush.
Unless he is willing to work with the Democrats (like Boehner did to get the new budget passed) and ignore the lunatic far right wing tea party he'll got a lot done and they'll be real commonsense bipartisan bills that will make it through the Senate and get signed into law. If he decides to be scared of the far right wing nut coalition and only puts what they want on the floor for votes, then nothing will get done and it'll be gridlock as usual. He can decide to be a great Speaker or a cowardly chump. It's up to him.
... is it not also incumbent that he (and the democrats) work with Republicans...
When your adversary wants to eliminate something entirely (Obamacare) while proposing no alternative whatsoever... What sort of "compromise" can even be envisaged?
The GOP House's idea of working together is to pass whatever they say to pass and have the President sign it. They only compromise when they have no other real option and the screwballs in the "Freedom Caucus" just want to destroy the government, just about any government.
Perhaps, but that was not the question which you failed to address.
Thanks anyway, but the question was rhetorical since the answer is obvious to all that the cooperation and compromise is supposed to flow in a single direction.
I don't want them to compromise at all. That only leads to more bad policy, loss of freedom, higher taxes, more debt and less economic opportunity. It's time for the opposition party to act like one and fight for what we believe in.
RIO, totally agree. When I speak to our Representative's staff their response is "he's the most conservative member and will not compromise". I'm like alright, but being ultra-conservative and not moving the country along legislatively is not job performance (IMO).
Often I remind them there is a constituency of 47K who voted for the Democrat and 8K that voted for the Independent who are deserving of representation. He received 78K votes, not a landslide by any means.
Basically their response is, Representative DesJarlais will not compromise his values and those that elected him.
You are still avoiding the question - it is a simple question.
If the Speaker (and the Republicans) need to cooperate with and compromise with the Democrats do not the Democrats also need to cooperate with and compromise with the Republicans?
If the Speaker (and the Republicans) need to cooperate with and compromise with the Democrats do not the Democrats also need to cooperate with and compromise with the Republicans?
I avoided nothing. I answered it. You can not compromise with a group who says it's my way or no way. There is no room at all for the Democrats TO compromise. None. Nada. Zip. You can not cooperate with someone who just plain refuses, completely and 100% to cooperate with you. That's the right wing of the GOP in the House and the Senate. A compromise on the Democrats part couldn't be anything except to just dissolve as a political party. The question was answered.
So If there is no room (or desire) for the Democrats to compromise with the Republicans why would the Republicans want to undertake a strategy of compromising with them.
As you note (and I agree) the Republicans of late have refused to compromise with the Democrats in getting meaningful legislation through the process and you are advocating that the Democrats should do the same even if the position of the Republicans softens.
That is the very definition of hyper-partisanship and a formula for gridlock in the congress.
So If there is no room (or desire) for the Democrats to compromise...
That's not what I said. The Democrats want to move forward, and they know that that means compromise. They know that they would have to cede on... something ... that must be suggested by the other camp.
This is the attitude of the Tea Party faithful: No conversation - none whatsoever - with the enemy!
... you are advocating that the Democrats should do the same...
Not at all! Certainly not!
For the moment, the Republicans want to repeal Obamacare. That isn't "compromise". They say, "repeal and replace"... but they never say what they would replace it with.
Everyone knows Obamacare can be improved. It is a kludge, an assemblage of elements that pleased various parties, in order to get the whole package passed. But to improve Obamacare (or anything else), the first step is to put forward some propositions.
What about the fact that there are Democrats who will follow their POTUS no matter what, even in the face of polls indicating a vast majority of their electorate wanting otherwise - no compromise there.
... there are Democrats who will follow their POTUS no matter what...
One of Obama's failures was his refusal to confront the wackos. It took him five years to understand that there was no point in even trying to "negotiate".
He began his Presidency by trying to recruit Chuck Grassley!
He drove progressives crazy by "negotiating with himself". He watered down progressive policies before putting them on the table, in the hope of getting some Republicans on board. Then, of course, the Republicans simply moved their objectives even further right. He was still offering more and more concessions when the Republicans shut the government down the first time.
Obama is a Rockefeller conservative. He is on the right of his party. I personally suspect him of having purposefully moved the overall spectrum to the right.
As for some Democrats following him blindly... I don't know who they are. Pelosi has frequently - publicly - expressed her differences. Granted, we haven't heard any Democrats decrying the fact that Obama is a Muslim socialist intent on destroying the Constitution...
Honestly, I have no idea where you come up with the idea that a majority of Americans want a Republican "outsider" to be president. The outsiders barely have a majority of Republican support. Republicans are about a third of the electorate so that puts you at about 17 -18% nationally. Do you think Ted Cruz is going to pick up 33% more of the total vote from the rest of the GOP, independents and Democrats ? lol. After people get wind of his ideas and philosophy, his totals will drop, not rise.
Even if Cruz were to get every Republican to vote for him he would still need a lot of independent votes. Of course that is true for any candidate , but other candidates are in a better position to win over independents than Cruz. Or Trump, or Carson.
I have no idea.
Will the House continue to repeal Obamacare every week?
Will the search for the truth about Benghazi continue eternally?
Boehner gave Ryan a fantastic going away present with the debt ceiling deal, so Ryan should be able to avoid any "shutdown" crisis until Obama is gone.
But what will Ryan do?
Nothing.
Is that an "empty nothing"... radio silence... nobody doin' nothin'
Or an "aggressive nothing"... full of sound and fury signifying nothing...
??
He will try and do something after Jan 2017 assuming he is still in the office. Until then I think he will be laying groundwork.
I agree with that... but until then? Can the Speaker of the House just disappear for 16 months?
IDK? I looked up speaker of the house and these are the facts:
Muhlenberg has a good little liberal arts college named after him.
So... maybe... in a couple hundred years there'll be a Ryan College?
... ... ... dubious...
Well let's see, perhaps the new speaker can take up tax reform, put forth legislation to undue Citizens United, I know...how about immigration reform.
All these issues are being discussed by the potential 2016 nominees, I say let the Republican controlled House and Senate start now. Since there is no guarantee they'll win the W.H., it'll give them something to do until election.
There's also a good chance that the Democrats will take back control of the Senate this election.
... Democrats will take back control of the Senate...
Oh joy!
Even more gridlock...
We could HAVE more gridlock? At least a Democratically controlled Senate will keep the brain dead idiots in the "Freedom Caucus" in the House in check if Ryan can't.
I would love to see Hillary Clinton vs. Ted Cruz.
I don't think the GOP will be crazy enough to nominate Cruz though.
They are wishing now that Romney were still an option.
That's true. Romney is waiting in the wings to be there Convention compromise candidate. He'd jump at the chance to lose the White House again. It would make him feel "relevant" again.
No one seriously believes Trump or Carson will be the GOP nominee. Even the GOP average voter is not that stupid. It'll be an establishment candidate because if it IS Trump or Carson, it'll be Goldwater all over again. A GOP version of what 1972 was like for the Democrats. Maybe worse. It'll be Rubio or Bush.
Ummm....
What will Santa be doing while Congress is undoing Citizens United?
Unless he is willing to work with the Democrats (like Boehner did to get the new budget passed) and ignore the lunatic far right wing tea party he'll got a lot done and they'll be real commonsense bipartisan bills that will make it through the Senate and get signed into law. If he decides to be scared of the far right wing nut coalition and only puts what they want on the floor for votes, then nothing will get done and it'll be gridlock as usual. He can decide to be a great Speaker or a cowardly chump. It's up to him.
Unless he is willing to work with the Democrats (like Boehner did to get the new budget passed) ...
Very true. But Boehner was free to do whatever he liked -- the lame duck's privilege! Will the wackos allow Ryan the same freedom? I doubt it...
Randy
Unless he is willing to work with the Democrats
Agreed, but is it not also incumbent that he (and the democrats) work with Republicans on issues important to them as well?
... is it not also incumbent that he (and the democrats) work with Republicans...
When your adversary wants to eliminate something entirely (Obamacare) while proposing no alternative whatsoever... What sort of "compromise" can even be envisaged?
The GOP House's idea of working together is to pass whatever they say to pass and have the President sign it. They only compromise when they have no other real option and the screwballs in the "Freedom Caucus" just want to destroy the government, just about any government.
Perhaps, but that was not the question which you failed to address.
Thanks anyway, but the question was rhetorical since the answer is obvious to all that the cooperation and compromise is supposed to flow in a single direction.
This looks like a compromise
Senate approves two-year budget deal in 3 a.m. vote
The hastert rule is not a prescription for compromise.
Kinda can't read it...
I don't want them to compromise at all. That only leads to more bad policy, loss of freedom, higher taxes, more debt and less economic opportunity. It's time for the opposition party to act like one and fight for what we believe in.
Gridlock leads to noting but legislative chaos and that is not good for the country
Gridlock means you don't have the votes needed to pass your crap. That is how the system was designed to work.
Nonsense
The system was designed for the two sides to work together
RIO, totally agree. When I speak to our Representative's staff their response is "he's the most conservative member and will not compromise". I'm like alright, but being ultra-conservative and not moving the country along legislatively is not job performance (IMO).
Often I remind them there is a constituency of 47K who voted for the Democrat and 8K that voted for the Independent who are deserving of representation. He received 78K votes, not a landslide by any means.
Basically their response is, Representative DesJarlais will not compromise his values and those that elected him.
Randy
You are still avoiding the question - it is a simple question.
If the Speaker (and the Republicans) need to cooperate with and compromise with the Democrats do not the Democrats also need to cooperate with and compromise with the Republicans?
A simple yes or no will suffice
If the Speaker (and the Republicans) need to cooperate with and compromise with the Democrats do not the Democrats also need to cooperate with and compromise with the Republicans?
I avoided nothing. I answered it. You can not compromise with a group who says it's my way or no way. There is no room at all for the Democrats TO compromise. None. Nada. Zip. You can not cooperate with someone who just plain refuses, completely and 100% to cooperate with you. That's the right wing of the GOP in the House and the Senate. A compromise on the Democrats part couldn't be anything except to just dissolve as a political party. The question was answered.
So If there is no room (or desire) for the Democrats to compromise with the Republicans why would the Republicans want to undertake a strategy of compromising with them.
As you note (and I agree) the Republicans of late have refused to compromise with the Democrats in getting meaningful legislation through the process and you are advocating that the Democrats should do the same even if the position of the Republicans softens.
That is the very definition of hyper-partisanship and a formula for gridlock in the congress.
Robert,
So If there is no room (or desire) for the Democrats to compromise...
That's not what I said. The Democrats want to move forward, and they know that that means compromise. They know that they would have to cede on... something ... that must be suggested by the other camp.
But the Republicans do not want to compromise. As Dean Moriarty says :
I don't want them to compromise at all.
This is the attitude of the Tea Party faithful: No conversation - none whatsoever - with the enemy!
... you are advocating that the Democrats should do the same...
Not at all! Certainly not!
For the moment, the Republicans want to repeal Obamacare. That isn't "compromise". They say, "repeal and replace"... but they never say what they would replace it with.
Everyone knows Obamacare can be improved. It is a kludge, an assemblage of elements that pleased various parties, in order to get the whole package passed. But to improve Obamacare (or anything else), the first step is to put forward some propositions.
Have you heard any from the GOP?
What about the fact that there are Democrats who will follow their POTUS no matter what, even in the face of polls indicating a vast majority of their electorate wanting otherwise - no compromise there.
... there are Democrats who will follow their POTUS no matter what...
One of Obama's failures was his refusal to confront the wackos. It took him five years to understand that there was no point in even trying to "negotiate".
He began his Presidency by trying to recruit Chuck Grassley!
He drove progressives crazy by "negotiating with himself". He watered down progressive policies before putting them on the table, in the hope of getting some Republicans on board. Then, of course, the Republicans simply moved their objectives even further right. He was still offering more and more concessions when the Republicans shut the government down the first time.
Obama is a Rockefeller conservative. He is on the right of his party. I personally suspect him of having purposefully moved the overall spectrum to the right.
As for some Democrats following him blindly... I don't know who they are. Pelosi has frequently - publicly - expressed her differences. Granted, we haven't heard any Democrats decrying the fact that Obama is a Muslim socialist intent on destroying the Constitution...
Honestly, I have no idea where you come up with the idea that a majority of Americans want a Republican "outsider" to be president. The outsiders barely have a majority of Republican support. Republicans are about a third of the electorate so that puts you at about 17 -18% nationally. Do you think Ted Cruz is going to pick up 33% more of the total vote from the rest of the GOP, independents and Democrats ? lol. After people get wind of his ideas and philosophy, his totals will drop, not rise.
Even if Cruz were to get every Republican to vote for him he would still need a lot of independent votes. Of course that is true for any candidate , but other candidates are in a better position to win over independents than Cruz. Or Trump, or Carson.