╌>

I Challenge You to Answer the Question Directly!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  11 years ago  •  103 comments

I Challenge You to Answer the Question Directly!

Many, many times I have read the following assertions on NewsTalkers' threads

1) "ISLAM/THE KORAN ADVOCATES THE MURDER OF (THOSE IT DEEMS) TO BE 'INFIDELS.'"
2) "RELIGIOUS BELIEFS TRUMP LAW"
Based on those premise (and ONLY those premises), I posit the following scenario and the QUESTION TO BE ANSWERED.
THE SCENARIO: A Muslim man comes to America legally and subsequently becomes an American Citizen.
In his tenth year as a citizen, he commits a murder his Islam religion and beliefs are insulted by a boisterous man in a public place in the presence of many on-lookers he retaliates by assaulting the man on-the-spot with several punches to the face which render him unconscious and cause him to be hospitalized.
The boisterous man/assault victim's family hire an attorney and file assault charges against the Muslim man.
The Muslim man is formally charged and in his jury-trial, HIS ATTORNEY PLEADS "INNOCENT" FOR HIS CLIENT CITING
* THE FIRST AMENDMENT and "its Guarantees of"RELIGIOUS FREEDOM"
and the premise that
* "RELIGIOUS BELIEFS TRUMP LAW"
THE QUESTION: HOW DO YOUAS A MEMBER OF THE JURY DECIDE -- "INNOCENT" OR "GUILTY"?And WHY?
_________________________________________
NOTE: I anticipate a lot of pontificating, pronouncements, dodges, derails and anything but direct answers.
Disappoint me.

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

NOTE: I anticipate a lot of pontificating, pronouncements, dodges, derails and anything but direct answers.

Disappoint me.
 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Umm, So the assault victim dies as a result of his injuries? Not meaning to be dense, just that you did not connect the two except inferentially.

The guy kills someone, charge him with murder. As a member of the jury, I would have to vote to convict the man of murder or aggravated manslaughter. So: Guilty. Seems fairly straightforward. The law is the law, and it gives no pass for any person killing another.... (unless you are OJGrin.gif )

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

His religion would be meaningless to me as a jury member. Christian, Muslim, Jewish, whatever. If the state proves their case beyond a reasonable doubt I'm going to vote to convict.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

No, of course he's not guilty! What?! Are you trying to stifle his religious rights?! Don't we have freedom of religion in America?!

/HUGE SARCASM/

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Who thinks religion triumphs law?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Brother, This one is easy.

The LAW deals with behavior, not belief

Religion deals with faith, not behavior.

Both attempt to establish individual morality, one by belief/choice, one by force of intimidation or fear of reprisal.

Both have blurred boundaries.

So your question amounts to how someone, or, in the macro sense, a society, should judge another.

Morality is individual, not societal, some will believe that the perpetrators acts as morally justified, they are judging based upon their own belief/morality. Others will believe that his acts are unjustified based upon their beliefs/moralities.

The law tries to codify general beliefs and moralities into societal rules based upon beliefs and moralities, to come to a just resolution of issues arising out of competing beliefs/moralities.

Another way to put it, one persons honest integrity is anothers fraudulence.

All we can do as a juror is relate how WE as individuals would have handled the situation, and judge accordingly.

All faith/beliefs understand that behavior is a choice, it is not compelled. Man being an imperfect being can be motivated to make choices that are not valid by any number of circumstances. Because of this there are consequences that we as a society have decided upon for certain behaviors. Again by our collective beliefs/faiths.

The question has no direct answer, I think you know that. It depends to much on our individual beliefs/faiths.

Some would think that the actions of the perpetrator were justified some will not. That is why we create laws. Based upon majority will.

To balance the different beliefs of the members in society into a workable whole.

I guess I've given you the why first, next comes is how I would decide.

I would decide that he is guilty, if the evidence establishes that to my satisfaction. If it doesn't, then he is innocent.

I would assume that since he has busted knuckles, bruises and abrasions all over the face/body of the other consistent with the busted knuckles, and twenty direct witnesses.

He's guilty. irrespective of his religion or any justification thereof.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Of course he's guilty. The states' most compelling interest is to prevent people from killing each other. So it doesn't matter what religion anyone in your scenario is.

Let me ask you, do you agree with justice scalia that Indians who use controlled substances as part of their religious ceremonies should be charged with felonious possession of controlled substances?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Sean, only the Native American Church (membership) 250,000 can use only one drug legally. That is peyote. No other group of Native American can use it legally. Of course we've used peyote for a 1,000 years, long before there was a SCOTUS or Scalia.

Do you believe that Indians should be restricted from the use of peyote in religious ceremonies? After all we used it long before America was America.

Mac, the man is guilty.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The first amendment does not guarantee murder under any religion.

A fair point thus indicating that "religious beliefs" don't trump laws without exceptions!

And whether or not Islam, as some here have claimed, allows for ideological/religiously-sanctioned killing, neither it, nor Christianity, nor any religious belief in-and-of-itself trumps the law in the United States.

Laws are laws and one cannot pick and chose which laws are trumped by religious beliefs if any!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So the assault victim dies as a result of his injuries? Not meaning to be dense, just that you did not connect the two except inferentially.

A fair point but either way, murder, aggravated assault the issue still is whether or not "religious beliefs" can be a viable defense for violating a law.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Who thinks religion triumphs law?

"Trumps law," Sean.

And it appears you've missed some of the articles and comments posted by those with whom you usually agree.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

o you believe that Indians should be restricted from the use of peyote in religious ceremonies?

No, but I'm not an absolutist.

Amac appears to be taking an absolutist opinion that there can be no exemptions from any laws for religious reasons. If that's your opinion, than you can't logically support an accommodation for Indians to use peyote.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The question has no direct answer, I think you know that. It depends to much on our individual beliefs/faiths.

In general, agreed; but specifically as asked namely, your verdict and the reason everyone can answer although the "whys" will vary I suspect.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

do you agree with justice scalia that Indians who use controlled substances as part of their religious ceremonies should be charged with felonious possession of controlled substances?

Native Americans have been granted certain exceptions to laws and those exceptions, when granted by law, ARE LAW.

If the controlled substance falls under a legal exception, then Scalia and I disagree.

The bigger caveat is in the fact that Native American culture WAS STOLEN BY THE GOVERNMENT --AS WERE THEIR LANDS AND OTHER POSSESSIONS!THAT GOVERNMENT NOW WANTS TO IMPOSE ITS CULTURE AND LAWS!

Your question is a good and thoughtful one, Sean, and you have my answer. If you were talking other activities like murder, robbery, rape, etc., I'd have a different answer.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Amac appears to be taking an absolutist opinion that there can be no exemptions from any laws for religious reasons. If that's your opinion, than you can't logically support an accommodation for Indians to use peyote.

Sean,

You reached that conclusion before you gave me a chance to answer your question.

Look below.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Easy - When in Rome, do as the Romans do. You must obey the laws of the country in which you find yourself, notwithstanding your religion.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

been granted certain exceptions to laws and those exceptions, when granted by law, ARE LAW.

So you believe its proper for the government to pick and choose which religions get exemptions from general laws?

THAT GOVERNMENT NOW WANTS TO IMPOSE ITS CULTURE AND LAWS!

So its unjust for the government to impose its culture on American citizens who profess to be members of an Indian church but its okay for the government to impose its culture and laws on members of other religions?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

The LAW deals with behavior, not belief

Religion deals with faith, not behavior.

That seems to sum up the distinction in a nutshell .

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Sean, it wasn't until 1978 that AIRFA was passed until that time we could not practice our religion...Guess who implemented that law that stopped our religions from being practiced..Yup, Christians and the US government.

I suggest that you use other examples, since you are not familiar with Indian history or law regarding such.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So you believe its proper for the government to pick and choose which religions get exemptions from general laws?

Come on, sean if I object to the GOVERNMENT STEALING LAND FROM NATIVE AMERICANS isn't it obvious that I don't believe that.

I explained exactly why the exception should apply to Native Americans.

So its unjust for the government to impose its culture on American citizens who profess to be members of an Indian church but its okay for the government to impose its culture and laws on members of other religions?

It's UNJUST TO IMPOSE ITS CULTURE ON A PEOPLE WHOSE CULTURE ITS STOLEN!

I take exception to your use of the word "profess" don't play games with me; I have been clear throughout.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

You are free to believe what ever you chose but when your belief infringes on the rights of others, there are consequences.

Dead on correct!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

This clerk is not standing at the counter of her office shooting non christians for breaking christian values

Check the word "ANALOGOUS".

comparable in certain respects, typically in a way that makes clearer the nature of the things compared

Trying to justify an act that is contrary to law based on one's religious beliefs is the issue be the law against murder, theft, jaywalking, or, willful misconduct as it applies to the law regarding public officials (as handed down by the SCOTUS in 2006).

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

It doesn't matter when or why it was passed.

Congress exempts followers of your religion from laws that it applies to everyone else, today, in 2015. Period. I don't have a problem with that, but let's be honest about what is happening.

Most people agree that reasonable religious exemptions should be made for their own religion, it's just when people are asked to extend that tolerance to others that problems arise.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I object to the GOVERNMENT STEALING LAND FROM NATIVE AMERICANS isn't it obvious that I don't believe that.


I don't follow. Congress pickedfollowersof theIndianreligion and granted themexemptionsfrom the law that it doesn't extend to others. So you believe Congress should exempt americancitizenwho are followers of theIndian religionfromgenerallaws but should never do that for other religions?

NJUST TO IMPOSE ITS CULTURE ON A PEOPLE WHOSE CULTURE ITS STOLEN!

I have no idea what that means. Requiring American Indians to follow general laws doesn't impose a culture upon them anymore than does the gay marriage ruling impose culture on those religions who abhor the idea.

Laws,especiallywhen the law becomes as all encompassing as it is now, imposes its cultureon those who disagree with it.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Sean, you may think it's doesn't matterwhenor way it was passed. There are millions that will disagree with you. First off why was the Indian religion outlawed in the first place. That truly seems Un-American, for a county that professes ''freedom of religion''.

BTW, only the Native American Church is covered by this law. NO other Indian religion has that exemption. It is far from covering all Native Americans.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

RE: UNJUST TO IMPOSE ITS CULTURE ON A PEOPLE WHOSE CULTURE ITS STOLEN!

I have no idea what that means.

That is quite obvious.

If someone stole your wallet then subsequently told you you no longer had no legal right to that wallet, would you not want to correct that, no just insult to injury, but INJURY ON TOP OF INJURY?

Requiring American Indians to follow general laws doesn't impose a culture upon them anymore than does the gay marriage ruling impose culture on those religions who abhor the idea.

IT'S THE INDIANS' COUNTRY, SEAN. The American Government stole it then passed laws after-the-fact to make the theft "LEGAL"!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

still comes down to refusing to issue lic for marriage and a Muslim killing some one. no comparison. No matter how you twist it. (typical, Leftist, twist to suit their agenda.)

PROJECTION!

No more explanations.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I think the point of the peyote issue is that allowing it does no harm to those not of that particular tribe, and in fact probably does no harm to those who have that privilege. I doubt that anyone would be exempted from a law that harms others, such as that for murder, or any crime that negatively affects those outside of the ones who have such exemption privilege.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

What matters is that Congress passed a law exempting some Native Americans from laws that apply to everyone else. The principle has been conceded, unless you believe the AIRFA should be repealed and practitioners of all Indian religions that use peyote ceremonially should be eligible for jail for practicing their religion.

Reasonable exemptions are perfectly consistent and necessary for any legal regime that tries to implement the right (and its an actual right you can find in the Constitution) for citizens to freely exercise their religion.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

No. it's not the Indians' country. Anymore than England is Rome's country or Celtic.

They lost. The world moves on. It's happened to everyone's ancestors since the beginning of time. People get displaced. Cultures are lost. No "culture" remains stagnant for centuries. People adapt. Its the story of humanity.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Don't straw man Sean.

The point is that the exemption does no harm to anyone inside or outside of the religion. It's that simple.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

They lost.

They were robbed.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

They were robbed.

So was England in 1066 . What's your point ?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Silly. He's guilty. His rights end where they infringe on others. This seems like a strawman.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Silly. He's guilty. His rights end where they infringe on others. This seems like a strawman.

If this kind of exercise is beyond your grasp, feel free to not participate; if your comment is to frustrate me and/or break 'em for me, to make me reconsider future attempts at intellectual exercises

YOU'RE SUCCEEDING; congratulations -- maybe I'll go somewhere else.

I am seeing this tactic all too often from a handful of members. Keep pissin' on the floor and stifle good conversation -- other sites have been brought down by this crap.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

The LAW deals with behavior, not belief

Religion deals with faith, not behavior.

Many faiths have law that accompanies belief. It is not that cut and dry.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

They were robbed.

I believe that North Americans are just now beginning to comprehend that, and are starting to attempt, at least, to pay amends.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

But either the laws of faith or of nation have in most cases accommodated each other. The problem appears to be where the laws of faith refuse to accommodate the laws of the nation. The laws of the nation serve the much greater majority, and must prevail.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

They lost. The world moves on. It's happened to everyone's ancestors since the beginning of time. People get displaced. Cultures are lost. No "culture" remains stagnant for centuries. People adapt. Its the story of humanity.

Except for the Palestinians, who seem to be supported in their claim by by the UN (UNRWA) and most of the rest of the world.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

No. it's not the Indians' country. Anymore than England is Rome's country or Celtic.

That is particularly absurd because not only were the lands stolen from them through invasion, blood and outright merciless massacre, Indian Reservations are today sovereign nations with many of their own laws.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

and are starting to attempt, at least, to pay amends.

Does this mean the French will be paying reparations to England for 1066 ?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I said North Americans, Petey. However the French (and the rest of Europe) are paying the price now. I'm glad it was years ago that I toured parts of Europe. North America still has a way to go but it's coming.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

They are paying a price Buzz but it is not reparations .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I put it a little more succinctly than you did sweets, (trying to keep personal beliefs out of the discussion)

Both have blurred boundaries.

Both effect each other greatly. Also, it depends on what one deems most important in life. Some view morality as most important, some not so important is just one way this appears.

For example try to answer this one question,

The ends justify the means, or, the means justify the ends? which is valid to YOU?

In my experience, both or a combination of the two can all be valid given the situation and needed result.

But most would call me a moral relativist at this point, which I'm not.

To me the best solution to anything is the solution that works in whatever situation that needs dealing with irrespective of my personal preference.

Platitudes of relativism serve no useful purpose except to say that the person spouting such has no plan and couldn't care less.

And a person like that is not engaged in his society.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Having killed a man once, wholly justified mind you, to prevent his killing others, doing such leaves you with an empty spot in your soul. One that you can never refill. So the question is a difficult one for me.

I would have to stand by the evidence, if the evidence proves he did it beyond any doubt then he deserves what he has coming, if it doesn't, then he receives nothing until such evidence comes to light that says he does.

I guess my answer would be I would be the person like the Henry Fonda character in "12 Angry Men" before they do anything they better have the goods.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

They lost. The world moves on. It's happened to everyone's ancestors since the beginning of time. People get displaced. Cultures are lost. No "culture" remains stagnant for centuries. People adapt. Its the story of humanity.

How 'bout if I kick your ass, take your house, kill some of your relatives, march what's left of your ass to Oklahoma and punctuate it all with a big "Fuck You" in the form of ex- post facto "laws" that make all of it "legal"?

Does your world "move on," do you accept it graciously and say, "no problem, cultures are lost -- hey, thanks -- I mean my culture was getting stagnant -- I'll just adapt -- and WTF, after all, that's 'the story of humanity'?"

It's easy to be philosophical when it's someone else's ass.

The idea of "Reparations" only offends those who are morally obligated to pay them!

 
 
 
Robert G
Freshman Silent
link   Robert G    11 years ago

When are you going back to Europe?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

How many Indians has that personally happened to?

All of those things have happened to pretty much everyone's ancestors.

Is your culture the same as your 19th century ancestors? Do you live the same way and believe the same things as the Macarthurs of 1850?

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    11 years ago

Dear A. Mac: I would vote guilty for breaking the criminal law of murdering another person.

It may be in satisfaction of a religious law. That is debatable.

Civil and criminal courts are courts of secular national legality, not religious or other forms of morality.

In a criminal court, national laws apply.

E.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

That seems to be the only solution. Give up all your property and leave.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

"This law has been codified as a statute in the American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978, and made part of the common law inPeyote Way Church of God v. Thornburgh, (5th Cir. 1991); [42] it is also in administrative law at the 21 C.F.R. 1307.31 . The C.F.R. part dealing with "SPECIAL EXEMPT PERSONS" states:

Section 1307.31 Native American Church. The listing of peyote as a controlled substance in Schedule I does not apply to the nondrug use of peyote in bona fide religious ceremonies of the Native American Church, and members of the Native American Church so using peyote are exempt from registration. Any person who manufactures peyote for or distributes peyote to the Native American Church, however, is required to obtain registration annually and to comply with all other requirements of law."

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

The full answer, not publicized nor addressed in further cases, was by Justice O'Conner - "Furthermore, society's interest in preventing trafficking in controlled substances was similarly central to effectuating Oregon's ban on peyote."

Oregon's ban on peyote is based on the trafficking/sale/distribution of Peyote and recreational use of peyote. As Oregon had no "caveats" for use of peyote, period, there was no allowance for the use of peyote in religious ceremonies - contrary to AIRFA - aviolation of Fed law.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

''How many Indians has that personally happened to?'' Tens of thousands Sean.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Sean - FYI - Indians are NOT covered under the U. S. Constitution, so your points are moot.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
The US government has killed tens of thousands of indians in the recent past?
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Not exactly "recent" - 89,768,000 since 1492, giving the NA's a population base of 234,000 in the 1930 U. S. Census. Think that fits the "tens of thousands", eh? (Jack Weatherford, "Indian Givers", Charles Mann, "1491")

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I was also speaking of the land grab of the ''Tribal Termination Act, 1953 - 73. Over 100 tribes lost there tribal affiliation and over 2,500,000 acres of land was sold off to non Indians. In fact one of the tribes was in your state of Wisconsin. The Menominee. You might want to ask them about it.

There are a hell of Indians alive today that remember that Sean.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

When are you going back to Europe?

It's a fair philosophical/metaphorical question and I'll give you a fair philosophical/metaphorical response.

At times, in litigations where a plaintiff seeking compensation for "damages," in some cases, "to be made whole," when that is not possible, the defense will respond with

"you can't put the toothpaste back into the tube"

a metaphor meaning that "no settlement can return the plaintiff's loss(es) in such away as to go back to what existed prior to the damage(s).

This is so with regard to the indignities and crimes against Native Americans; and while "the toothpaste cannot be put back in the tube," and, since the original perpetrators are long gone, a new "tube" should rightfully be given by "the sons of the perpetrators."

In other words, the sins of the father will be visited upon the children

Exodus 20:5

The "son's" aren't going back to Europe, Robert G, nor is the moral obligation of reparation excused because the "sons" and not the "fathers" would be the ones to pay. Would you deny the return of the stolen artwork and other material items to the Jews because Hitler and the Third Reich isn't around to make the returns and reparations?

I have given you the time and effort of a response let's keep it civil and respectful.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

1066 . France owes England reparations . Are they going to happen ? Don't hold your breath ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I believe the Muslim man would be guilty by committing assault and it would appear in this situation charged with second degree murder. This is pretty obvious in this case to me and religious beliefs could not be used as an excuse. The Supreme Court doesn't write laws. Congress writes laws and the State Legislatures write the laws. The Supreme Court has the authority to interpret them.

I have no problem with same sex marriage as I feel it is not my authority to deny anyone the dignity to marry the one he or she loves, but I do have a problem with the lack of separation of powers.

I believe in following the guidelines outlined in the Constitution which does not give the Supreme Court the authority to write laws.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Now this ideal is wrong. A persons rights end at the tip of his nose. Not the tip of the other persons nose. The space in between two people, is free space, not controlled by anyone.

Such understanding, is paramount to libertarian ideals.

When you say that your rights ends at the tip of "HIS" nose, you are taking control of all the space around you as your dominion. You are also claiming that he has no right to that space.

Libertarianism is not expansive like that, libertarianism clearly says that the rights of the individual to be secure in his space and person are inviolate. It says nothing to the space surrounding you.

It clearly stands for the principle that you only have the rights you can defend. How can you defend space you have no control over?

You can't

Hence, your rights only extend to the tip of YOUR nose. AS does his.

Everything else is being part and parcel of the collective, which destroys individualism.

Everyone loves and strives to be libertarian, so few actually understand what that means.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The idea of "Reparations" only offends those who are morally obligated to pay them!

Which is a pretty clear statement of thinking that I should be held responsible for what my forefathers did before me. Or, better put, (keeping the racial component in the mix) I should be held responsible for what my RACIAL ancestors (white eurpoeans) did before me.

Is it easy to be philosophical when it's someone else's ass on the line. Well, the argument of racial justice in today's world puts my ass on the line.

Directly.

All your descendants are directly, legally responsible in today's world for what their forefathers did centuries before.

ALL of Bernie Madoff's children should go to jail for Bernie's crimes. All Germans should be executed for Hitlers crimes. OJ Simpson's children should pay for the crimes of his father.

For Christ's sake, why are the Egyptians still around? the Italians? the Greeks? The English? WE should systematically wipe Serbia off the face of the earth for their crimes shouldn't we?

Where does that lead us to?

The French demanded reparations so severe from the Germans at the end of WWI that it was a direct cause of WWII.

Anger begets anger. Hate begets hate. reparations demand reparations. (or revenge)

That's why I ask the question about actions when you have hold of the handle.

(handle being a reference to the firing "Handle" of the artillery piece. ie you think your justified when you have the greater political power, or you perceive your self as having that power)

You become what you claim to hate.

Seems like neither side is any better than the other to me.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

1066 . France owes England reparations . Are they going to happen ? Don't hold your breath ...

Not at all the issue; whether a moral, ethical or legal obligation, there is no ABSOLUTE ABSOLUTION of individuals, entities or governments that stake claim to that which they are not rightfully entitled.

The failure of one to pay for a wrong does not justify the subsequent, same failure of others -- nor the notion that "two wrongs make a right"!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The Supreme Court doesn't write laws. Congress writes laws and the State Legislatures write the laws. The Supreme Court has the authority to interpret them.

And when an interpretation sustains a particular law like any law, there are consequences for the failure to abide!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

ALL of Bernie Madoff's children should go to jail for Bernie's crimes. All Germans should be executed for Hitlers crimes. OJ Simpson's children should pay for the crimes of his father.

I deem that hyperbole, my friend; a better interpretation would be that the if/when the children of perpetrators benefit from the "sins of their fathers," justice has not only been denied -- it's been corrupted and "injustice" prevails.Not the best of precedents for the future of a civilized society.

The ideal not realized does not excuse the moral debt of repayment. If your great-grandfather murdered mine, took over his possessions and wrote laws to make both acts "legal," those ill-gotten possessions, while "legally" yours, are morally and ethically mine. While you couldn't, under the law, be made to compensate me and/or return the possessions, out of a sense of "fairness," you could.

AND THEREIN IS THE KEY; "FAIRNESS" is an orphan in the world and the "parent" named "FUCK YOU I'VE GOT MINE" is to a great extent why we are, where we are today!

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Talk of "reparations" is a philosophical discussion. To make it reality, in America, you would have to pass legislation authorizing such. The vast majority of Congresspeople would be voted out in their next election if they voted to fund reparations. So they will never do so. It's not even viable as a point of serious discussion.

So we have a philosophic discussion. Do the children have to pay for the sins of the fathers? Like many philosophic discussions, there is no answer. Philosophy asks questions, it doesn't necessarily answer them. In many cases there are no answers.

We can't go back and change history, and there is no such thing as fair and unfair in a historical sense. It is what it is.

In the present and planning for the future, we can try and apply fairness. American Indians suffer prejudice and discrimination today, and the wider culture should address it and remedy it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Yeah JR; I have to agree that politicians who do the right things are likely not reelected, that because there are too many people in this country who don't want the right thing -- they want the selfish thing, the myopic thing!

So, they punish the politician who does the right thing, reward and reelect politician who does the wrong thing --and then the bitch that government doesn't work!

Fascinating and nauseating!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Reparations are not what most Indians want. I am a member of various Indian organizations, and an active participant in meeting and discussions in those organizations.

The answer is fairly simple, and one that the government doesn't want to hear. It's called "Honor the Treaties''...simple isn't it. The treaty is supposed to be the highest law in the land, yet each of the treaties signed with various Indian tribes has been broken by the US government.

We can't go back and change history, it is what it is. But the government can and should honor their word. That would help restore our faith in the government.

If you would like to see how the government has screwed the Indian. Goggle the Corbel Settlement. It will give you an insight to the dealing between the US government and Indian tribes. It's not pretty, but in the end after decades of court cases, in which the government lost everyone, a settlement was put forth by the government. It was accepted for pennies on the dollar owed us. (Personally I would have not agreed to it, but that's another story).

There is one other simple thing that would help. And that is an apology for the wrongs. Just a few words that seem incapable of being uttered from the mouths of politicians.

There you have it from a Indian. Accept it or not, that isn't my concern. What is my concern is that the U.S. government honors it's word.

Prejudice and discrimination against Indians is a reality. For those of you who wish to avoid or deny that it is reality, that's your choice, but don't tell an Indian that it doesn't exist.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Treaties that are still in effect should be honored. An apology by the U.S. government is fine with me, but there is no doubt that it would be approached by many many many people in the same way they would approach reparations. "Why should I apologize for something I didn't do?" . They would see a US government apology as representing them individually, and they would not approve. Thus there would once again be negative election implications for many of the people who pushed for the apology.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

In other words, they don't have the balls to apologize to their own citizens.

Actually there was a watered down apology, and it was hidden in the back of a defense bill. No one ever saw it, nor did it really apologize.

The U.S. has apologized before and paid reparations. To the Japanese for the internment camps. Yet to say those simple words to a whole race of people that are U.S. citizensisn't something that they feel is important. What a fucking joke.

Canada, Australia and New Zealand all have done it, but the supposed ''moral compass'' of the world can't.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Look at certain people on NT as representative of part of the American people Kavika. Do they sound ready to apologize to American Indians? lol

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

What is my concern is that the U.S. government honors it's word.

I think Brother, that all Americans would like the government to honor it's word. It would be a pleasant turn of advents wouldn't it be?

I wish it would also, if only to truly be a nation of the people by the people and for the people. When governments get too big, in the sense of being full of themselves, we all suffer. It's not just limited to the Indians.

Unfortunately, in terms of settlement, there isn't enough justice in the world to settle all wrongs.

And, just as unfortunately, justice is truly blind, and doesn't give one whit to apology or even seeing that it was wrong in the first place.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

You once said that hyperbolic rhetoric can deliver a message more profoundly and directly than any reasoned statement could. Yes it was hyperbole with a point. The real point is that are the benefits of the original sin worth the cost of the sins to follow.

Fairness is an orphan in the world yes, only if fairness actually exists. Which I don't believe that it does. Fairness is only inculcable by those holding the handle. which means in the context I specified above. The winners decide for themselves what fairness actually is for the environment they are in. Is that "JUST" No, but it is the way of the world when one group has power over another.

SO in essence, our positions are in complete agreement, hyperbole notwithstanding.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

So, they punish the politician who does the right thing, reward and reelect politician who does the wrong thing --and then the bitch that government doesn't work!

Yeah, and riot in the streets and burn things down when they do not get their way. But then such really highlights the irony of them electing the people that refuse to give them their way.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Too many Americans do one of the following:

1) Sit on their dead asses on election day, don't vote, then bitch that "it doesn't matter, all politicians are the same failing to understand that tossing out incumbents, over time, will send the appropriate message.

2) Vote their race (all races), religion, gender and/or special interest at the expense of utilitarian issues/options, often to the detriment of their own economic and other interests.

Stupid is as stupid does.

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Guilty.

Muslims aren't actually humans. (just kidding)

Freedom of speech means being able to insult a religion without being assaulted.

Besides, Muslims are a scourge on civilised society, who cares what they want, they're animals.

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Example:

This is freedom of speech, but someone should still shoot these fucks in the face.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Muslims aren't actually humans. (just kidding)

Freedom of speech means being able to insult a religion without being assaulted.

Besides, Muslims are a scourge on civilised society, who cares what they want, they're animals.

You aren't exactly a fountain of consistency, are you? You contradict yourself in the span of three sentences.

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

How many beheadings, stoning of rape victims, and acid thrown in the faces of little girls does it take to realize that we are dealing with barbarism?

Not too many for me, perhaps you need more.

Maybe you should spend 30 minutes on you tube, so you can awake from your slumber.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

This is freedom of speech, but someone should still shoot these fucks in the face.

Why?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Will a moderator please flus

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Cry havoc! and let slip the dogs of war!

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Because they are worthless pieces of shit, calling for violence, and they should be exterminated.

Why else?

Do you think they have some important message to convey? Some wisdom in their guttural, barely understandable, garbled utterances?

You think some kernel of wisdom will fall from their gullah mouths?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

I was just commenting about how you can't put three sentences together without contradicting yourself.

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Life is filled with little contradictions, it's how we exterminate those contradictions that matters.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

No, but I disagree with everything the Klan has to say also, however (as the saying goes) I will support to the death their right to say it. If I agree that we should shut up a group who is saying things we don't like, then sooner or later any groups that I am in will no longer have the freedom of speech either. As long as they don't act on what they are calling for, then they have the right to say it. If you strongly disagree with them, put together a group of protesters and shout back at them. If someone does act on what they are calling for, then they will be caught, put on trial and if convicted (depending on the state) they will die for doing it.

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Show me the video of the Klan marching around, armed, calling for the murder of the police.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Bla bla bla

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Calling for the murder of police? I know of no such video. I do, however, know of seeing the Klan on the news marching around calling for the deaths of Black people. Or are Black people somehow less human in your eyes then the police? What about a Black cop. Do you get just as angry if a Black cop is killed as if a White one is?

 
 
 
Joey Giordano
Freshman Silent
link   Joey Giordano    11 years ago

Good show John, that's the most lucid insight you've ever uttered.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Show me the video of the Klan marching around, armed, calling for the murder of the police.

Is all right with you if they just hate blacks and Jews?

Is is possible that hatred based on blanket indictments of any demographic may be flawed in some way(s)? Like yours for example?

KKK Distributing Packets With Their Manifesto And Candy In North Carolina County

The Ku Klux Klan have been distributing recruitment literature in Eden and Reidsville, North Carolina communities recently, according to the Rockingham County Sheriffs Office.

Residents in those communities reported finding packets that contain the KKKs manifesto, along with some candy in the packet, at the edge of their driveways.

The Sheriffs Office said:

The Rockingham County Sheriffs Office has received notifications over the past few days from several residents of Eden and Reidsville that the Traditionalist American Knights of the Klu Klux Klan (KKK) have been disseminating literature in the area. The packet, which most people have reported was left at the edge of their driveway, contains the groups manifesto, candy and is apparently geared towards recruitment.

Although the distribution of such material is not prohibited by law, Sheriff Sam Page wants to notify area residents that this activity is going on in case they receive such a packet of materials on their property.

...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

How many beheadings, stoning of rape victims, and acid thrown in the faces of little girls does it take to realize that we are dealing with barbarism?

These are at the hands of every, single Muslim in the world is that your position?

Maybe you should spend 30 minutes on you tube, so you can awake from your slumber.

Maybe you should develop some perspective.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Tell us something we don't already know! Grin.gif

But the real issue is what to do about it!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I sometimes, only sometimes mind you, sort of wish we had compulsory voting here in the US like they do in Australia. I wonder what kind of country we would have if everyone HAD to vote?

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

THAT I would love to seeGrin.gif

 
 

Who is online




CB


71 visitors